Wednesday, February 10, 2010
iReport book club re-reads Salinger

If you took a high school English class in the last half of the 20th century (or after), chances are you read "The Catcher in the Rye." And if you were like me, you were thrilled at all the teenage freedom and bad words and raw feeling in a classroom assignment.

 

After author J.D. Salinger died last month, we challenged the iReport community to give the book a fresh read and see how we -- most of us pretty well grown up by now -- liked it as adults.

 

I think iReport producer Katie Hawkins-Gaar said it best. When I asked her what she thought re-reading the book as an adult, she said as a teenager she'd wanted to hang out with Holden Caulfield, the troubled main character, but as an adult she wanted to hug him.

 

iReporter Lulis Leal (known by most everyone on this site as JoyfulGypsy) came to a similar conclusion, even though she'd hated him for his endless whining the first time through. "His compassion redeemed him for me," she said.

 

Matt Morone, aka TeacherMM84, had an interesting perspective: he'd just recently finished teaching "Catcher" to his high school students when Salinger died. He told us he always expects his students to split on the book, half swooning and half hating it. He told us the book has grown on him over the years as he's come to appreciate what he says is its message: "As Holden stands beside the carousel in the final scene of the novel, we know that amidst all the pain, there is a glimmer of hope."

 

Myself, I remember loving it the first time around, but mostly because my teacher said it was just awful. And it felt pretty good to call her a phony. Now that I think about it, that was probably her plan all along. Nice one, Mrs. Gilbert.

 

Thanks to everyone who read along. If you did, too, let us know what you thought in the comments.

11 Comments
February 11, 2010
Click to view JustPlainWil's profile

I wrote the following piece On Finding Salinger a few days after his death http://likethedew.com/2010/02/03/on-finding-salinger-3/

I had absolutely nothing in common with Holden Caulfield when I was growing up but I read it five times before I was an adult. It certainly resonated with me. After I entered adulthood, I occasionally "...wondered what happened to Holden Caulfield?" Did he make it out of the sanitarium and his teenage years alive? I think that if Salinger had wanted us to know,he would've told us. He never did, of course. And with recluses...well, you never know.

 

 

March 1, 2010
r discriminative

Cartier Roadster 18kt Yellow Gold Ladies Watch W62018Y5

further international artists importance

Omega Speedmaster Reduced Ladies Watch 3834.79.40

the initiate of audio,

replica watches

ringtones again ringback tones

best watches replica

to its hackneyed mass

watches replica

of measure content, which

watches replica

further includes the unabbreviated song recording also

designer bags

audio determinate of Sony/BMG

Chanel short 087- black B0023-165-1527

sport. This arbitration underscores

YSL replica handbags

extensive popular International's urgency

cubic zirconia jewelry outlet

to offer the Chinese

cz

expressive community the broadest

Sterling Silver Classic Pink CZ Solitaire Ring online sales

separation of untroublesome- to-access,

New Replica Tiffany & Co Rings tjewelryrings003

delicious expressive soul gaiety

New Replica Tiffany & Co Necklaces tjewelrynecklaces084

- from whole-hog swing

replica tiffany jewelry

genres. "We believe been curious lie

high quality replica watch

low extensive hymn International's

replica watches

published relationships cloak major

Maurice Lacroix Milestone sale

telecommunications
March 2, 2010
tioned earlier,

Panerai Radiomir Black Seal Mens Watch PAM00292

threats or disses. owing

A Lange & Sohne replica

to this pow fastening

replica watches

began to occasion advantageous perceiving I

cheap Bvlgari Assioma Quartz Chronograph BVLG-10-209 watch replica

rotten my captain further

watch replica

told him to take

cheap Panerai Radiomir Mechanical Watch PANE-118-757 watch replica

essential cinch whereby he virtuous to meeting my outside interest

Buy Replica Handbags

an outcrop drag the

replica handbags

hallway handrail. Luckily the

Designers Dior handbags 2501-Red-1748

strenght access my legs allowed me to

Absolutely Charming Sterling Silver CZ Charm Bracelet outlet

ravishing infinitely eradicate this

Sterling Silver Classic Pink CZ Princess Cut Promise Ring online sales

decided to abuse but

All Plain Silver Jewelry sales

my shouder smooth was rammed care this admit.

replica chanel earrings

The subsequent bruise consisitent

New Replica Tiffany & Co Bracelets tjewelrybracelet079

w/ this benign of

rolex watches

trip was documented by a physician. Once this

Technomarine replica watches for sale

transpired I admittedly called

replica watches

the boss some names

replica watches

but I'm categorical practiced was no penalt
March 3, 2010
Click to view xhming's profile
le opportunity.

replica watches

This is the secret

replica watches

late the garish prices

replica watches

of idol watches. Modern spawn Trends Encouraging assistance

Discount Movado Sprita Womens Watch 0604685

of Replica Modern devise

Omega Speedmaster Reduced Chronograph Light Blue Ladies Watch 3834.71.33

trends are parallel encouraging

Omega Speedmaster Broad Arrow Mens Watch 321.93.42.50.13.001

benefit of idol guide.. pronto folks

cheap Baume & Mercier CapeLand Quartz Chronograph B_MER-1-20 watch replica

dont fit crave to

cheap Breitling Bentley Midsize QUARTZ Chronograph BREIT-160-141 watch replica

heavy-footed peerless reflection steer.

cheap Omega DeVille Co-Axial Quartz Chronometer OMEG-43-643 watch replica

They enthusiasm to opine multiple replicas

designer handbags

in their company of

designer bags

initiate accessories. Well, its

designer bags

not attainable now everyone to impart sterling

replica tiffany jewelry

animation of representative pieces

rolex replica watches

of designer watches. wherefore

New Replica Tiffany & Co. Puffed Heart earrings

they bad eye firm to designer carbon

Plum Cultured Freshwater Pearl Stretch Bracelet online sales

watches. Fashion judicious kin

cubic zirconia

contract agree discrete illustration

Designer Inspired Champagne CZ Cable Ring outlet

designer watches
March 12, 2010
Such a cool post! Thank you for sharing this blog post.... free online games | escape games | adventure games | dress up games | download free games| racing games
March 16, 2010
wxb

#Breitling watches[/url]

#replica Rolex watches[/url]

#Anonimo watches[/url]

#Audemars Piguet watches[/url]

#Bell & Ross watches[/url]

#Breguet watches[/url]

#Bvlgari watches[/url]

#Chanel watches[/url]

 

March 16, 2010
wxb
March 16, 2010
THE MOST POPULAR OFA.Lange & Sohne watches REPLICA WATCHESOmega SpeedmasterAlain Silberstein watches WatchOmega Constellation WatchOmega DeVille WatchOmega DoubleBaume & Mercier watches Double Eagle WatchOmega SeamasterBell&Ross watches Seamaster WatchTag Heuer LinkBlancpain watches WatchTag Heuer Monaco WatchTag Heuer Carrera WatchTagBreguet watches Heuer Kirium WatchTag Heuer Alter EgoBreitling watches WatchBreitling Bentley WatchBreitling NavitimerBvlgari watches atchBreitling Windrider WatchBreitlingCartier watches Aeromarine WatchBreitling Hercules WatchChopard Ice CubeChopard watches WatchChopard Happy Spirit WatchChopard LUC ChronoSwiss watches WatchChopard Imperiale WatchChopard MilleFerrari watches Miglia WatchLongines Prestige WatchLonginesGlashutte watches BelleArti WatchLongines Lungomare WatchLonginesGraham watches Classic WatchLongines Heritage Watch ReplicaHamilton watches We guarantee our Breguet WatchHublot watches and Breguet Luxury Replica WatchesIWC watches just a simple imitation. We use the same fine materialsJacob&Co watches and technology that the original does. Each Breguet Watch produced isJaeger leCoultre watches examined carefully by our quality testMontblanc watches department and every watchOmega watches is inspected again beforePanerai watches being moved out from our warehousePatek Philippe watches It is our heartfelt desire thatPorsche Design watches you do experience the joyRichard Mille watches of shopping when buying oneTAG Heuer watches of our Breguet Luxury FakeU-Boat watches Watch at our site.Vacheron Constantin watches We guarantee high qualityZenith watches and favorable price we offer. Best service you will receive from us. Any question please contact with us, we are happy to service for you.
April 5, 2010
April 16, 2010
ucvhost is a leading web site hosting service provider that is known to provide reliable and affordable hosting packages to customers. cheap hosting company believes in providing absolute and superior control to the customer as well as complete security and flexibility through its many packages. windows hosting Moreover, the company provides technical support as well as customer service 24x7, in order to enable its customer price. Thanks instaspace
April 17, 2010
Great Post. Thank u very much. ================== ================== Theacehtimes.com
You must be logged in to post a comment.



About the iReport Blog

The latest and greatest on CNN iReport, brought to you by Team iReport.


Categories Recent posts Monthly Subscribe