Share this on:
 E-mail
33
VIEWS
57
COMMENTS
 
SHARES
About this iReport
  • Not verified by CNN

  • Click to view k3vsDad's profile
    Posted June 19, 2014 by
    k3vsDad
    Location
    Farmersburg, Indiana
    Assignment
    Assignment
    This iReport is part of an assignment:
    Sound off

    More from k3vsDad

    Did We Learn Anything from Viet Nam?

     

    It is 2014.

    It has been 40 years since the US of A pulled out of Viet Nam.

    All these decades ago what did the US learn from that failed war?

    Americans are tired of war - Iraq, Afghanistan.

    We are afraid another war may be on the horizon.

    That fear seems even more justified with the current crisis in Iraq.  That fear is coming to fruition with American special forces being  deployed as "advisers" and not in a "combat role".

    One lesson was readily learned.

    That lesson was in the way, we the people treat our returning troops.  Our military personnel are greeted with hugs, kisses, bands playing  today.

    Our men and women returning from the Indo-China theater  were greeted with boos, protests, spit, having things thrown at them,  ostracized and ignored.

    That has changed.

    But let's look at the failure of Viet Nam from a different perspective, the lessons we apparently didn't learn.

    For the last decade and a half, the nation has been embroiled in two  wars (interventions). The one was in Iraq, toppling Sadaam Hussein, and  enmeshing the US for eight years.

    Now we have left and it looks similar to what happened when and after Saigon fell all over again.

    Now we are once more back in that country.

    The other war is a decade long in Afghanistan, a nation that gave aide  and shelter to Osama Bin Ladin. Bin Ladin has been sent to hell in  Pakistan, so why are we still in Afghanistan?

    Let's for a  moment look at the fact that politics was the biggest cause of the  losses and defeat in Viet Nam. Politicians in Washington D.C. were  directing military operations while the Generals were screaming about  the tactics, the strategies and the ineptitude.

    But the Generals' words kept falling on deaf ears. The politicians knew better.

    Supposedly we had learned the lesson from Viet Nam to let the Generals  conduct the war and keep the politicians busy fighting among themselves.

    Apparently we didn't learn that lesson.

    From the mistakes and ineptitude of Donald Rumsfeld and Dick Cheney and  the Administration of George W. Bush on to the continuing political  gambles of the Barack Obama Administration, the conflicts in Iraq and  continiuing in Afghanistan have been complicated by politicians sticking  their noses into the war rooms.

    Teachers were asked their  views on the lessons from Viet Nam. If being graded by these teachers it  would appear the US has not learned. The teachers views on the lessons  can be read here:

    http://enotes.com/history/discuss/what-lessons-might-vietnam-war-teach-us-95421

    Note this quote from a book that looks at the lessons from Viet Nam:

    It  is popular today to say that Vietnam could not have been won. The  message emerging from this new study, on the contrary, is that despite  some horrible blunders and incompetent political leadership at the  highest levels, by 1973 the war had essentially been won. Partisan  politics and mutual mistrust in Washington kept that message from  reaching the right people, and a misunderstanding of public opinion  prompted Congress to outlaw further U.S. military involvement  essentially snatching defeat from the jaws of victory.

    http://cap-press.com/books/isbn/9780890896488

    Does this sound familiar?

    It could be said about Afghanistan and Iraq.

    Then again perhaps I am writing and speaking to those who have no  understanding or memory of that tragedy that lasted for well over a  decade.

    Public opinion polls over  the years consistently show that two of three Americans judge the  Vietnam War to have been a "mistake." Unfortunately, few claim to know  what the U.S. should have done differently.

    Over half do not have "a clear idea" what the war was about; a third  can't even remember which side we supported. The problem is even worse  for American youth - future citizens and leaders - who have no  experience of the war and little or no knowledge of it.

    Many knowledgeable adults cannot talk to youth about the war. They  served in Vietnam and memories of that experience still are too painful.

    http://globaled.org/curriculum/viet.html


    Looking at the current state of affairs, it would seem we have learned nothing from Viet Nam.

    Iraq is mired in civil war or falling into the camp of Iran as another province of a nation that supports worldwide terrorism.

    Are we still allowing politicans to dictate military action without taking into account long-term issues and concerns?

    Are we still allowing poiliticans to do what is popular to keep power  without looking to see how much damage we are causing for the future?

    Have we learned nothing four decades after Viet Nam?

    I first wrote most of that back on January 4, 2012.

    In light of what is occurring in Iraq now, it would appear that perhaps we are once more repeating the past.

    When we went into Iraq over 10 years ago, the aim was to make the  country a shining beacon of democracy in the Middle East. That has  turned out to be a pipe dream, a flight of fantasy.

    We thought  with ridding Iraq of Sadaam Hussein we could "win the hearts and minds"  of the people. This was part of the objective when our nation was  involved in a 10+ years war in Viet Nam.

    How wrong we were then and now.

    What our politicians failed to do was look long term.

    What our politicians failed to understand was the deep divide and ancient grudge match ongoing between Sunni and Shia.

    What our politicians failed to do was understand the yearning of ethnic tribes for identity and self-rule.

    Today the dismissed neo-conservative push for "regime change" is walking the halls of the White House.

    The scenes now showing on our television screens of what is happening in Iraq appear eerily familiar.

    Could what is happening with and in Iraq be a foreshadowing of what will be for Afghanistan?

    From the Cornfield, we are in a hopeless situation with no chance of winning in the traditional sense.

    We failed to accomplish what we set out to do. Contary to former  President George W. Bush's pronouncement of "mission accomplished", we  left Iraq with mission unaccomplished.

    Now we are back with little hope that we can succeed.

    When a people does not want to move beyond thousand-year old feuds, we  are as helpless as those who tried to stop the Hatfields and McCoys.

    Have we learned nothing from Viet Nam?

    What do you think of this story?

    Select one of the options below. Your feedback will help tell CNN producers what to do with this iReport. If you'd like, you can explain your choice in the comments below.
    Be and editor! Choose an option below:
      Awesome! Put this on TV! Almost! Needs work. This submission violates iReport's community guidelines.

    Comments

    Log in to comment

    iReport welcomes a lively discussion, so comments on iReports are not pre-screened before they post. See the iReport community guidelines for details about content that is not welcome on iReport.

    Add your Story Add your Story