Share this on:
 E-mail
40
VIEWS
42
COMMENTS
 
SHARES
About this iReport
  • Not verified by CNN

  • Click to view k3vsDad's profile
    Posted July 30, 2014 by
    k3vsDad
    Location
    Farmersburg, Indiana
    Assignment
    Assignment
    This iReport is part of an assignment:
    Sound off

    More from k3vsDad

    Marriage, Equality and the Constitution

     

    Blame  it on what seems to be a recurring bronchial infection wreaking havoc  with my mind and body for my thoughts turning today with questions and  pondering marriage, equality and the Constitution.

    As  my brain has been churning, I have begun to wonder if both proponents  and opponents of providing equality to same-gender couples for legal  recognition of their relationships with the wrong lens.

    Is  the real issue whether the government - state or federal - may have any  say or may provide any benefits to any couples and which of those  couples who commit to one another may receive legal recognition?

    Opponents  of same-gender equality cite religious beliefs for opposition to  conferring legal recognition to same-gender couples. Opponents note that  marriage is a religious sacrament or at least a religious ceremony.

    If  indeed marriage is religious in nature, should this be an alarm  sounding that the "Establishment Clause" of the 1st Amendment to the  Constitution is being violated?

    Opponents  cite biblical grounds for keeping legal recognition limited to one man  and one woman. Opponents cite "Christian" principles to deny equality to  same-gender couples.

    But, there is the rub.

    Not  all Christian denominations, churches, sects, organizations define or  translate the Bible the same way - even when it comes to same-gender  couples. Some churches now solemnize same-gender unions and even allow  gays and lesbians to fill the pulpit.

    That automatically pits conflicting positions among those of the Christian persuasion.

    Again the wire is tripped on a possible violation of the "Establishment Clause".

    Which Christian belief is marriage or denial of equality to same-gender couples based?

    For government to intervene and choose one over the other is a clear violation of the Clause.

    Then you have other religions which may or may not also see marriage as something holy.

    If  the marriage laws are based on a certain Christian belief, does this  not give preference to that belief over the beliefs of other religions  and thus unconstitutional under the Clause?

    What about those with no religious persuasion or no belief in a higher power?

    Should  those without religion be subjected by the government to a Christian  sacrament in order to receive legal recognition of their commitment to  one another?

    This again would have red flags flying.

    Is  not the correct constitutional path for government, both state and  federal, to remove any and all laws providing for legal recognition to  committed couples from the books?

    Is  not the correct constitutionally mandated course of action to provide  no tax breaks, tax deductions or treat any taxpayer differently based on  whether the couple has gone through a religious ceremony determined to  be the belief of a specific sect of Christianity?

    As one CNN iReporter, Democritic, has pointed out many times that he, as a single man, is being discriminated against by the tax laws.

    Should not all taxpayers be treated with equality?

    To  maintain constitutional muster, should not the states and the federal  government be instructed that all laws on marriage or recognition of  married couples with special benefits not afforded single taxpayers be  scrapped?

    Maybe it is the infection.

    Maybe it is the meds.

    From  the Cornfield, jumbled thoughts passing through this fevered brain this  last day of July make life interesting if not delusional at times.

    What do you think of this story?

    Select one of the options below. Your feedback will help tell CNN producers what to do with this iReport. If you'd like, you can explain your choice in the comments below.
    Be and editor! Choose an option below:
      Awesome! Put this on TV! Almost! Needs work. This submission violates iReport's community guidelines.

    Comments

    Log in to comment

    iReport welcomes a lively discussion, so comments on iReports are not pre-screened before they post. See the iReport community guidelines for details about content that is not welcome on iReport.

    Add your Story Add your Story