About this iReport
  • Not verified by CNN

  • Click to view Shambala's profile
    Posted August 14, 2014 by
    Dharamshala, India
    This iReport is part of an assignment:
    Life in China

    More from Shambala

    UK politician under fire over comment that 'Tibetans live happily'

    Tell us your storyDharamshala: - Lord Davidson, a senior British politician blasted insensitive by Tibetans and Tibet supporters after making comment on Tibet.

    Neil Davison, Labor's shadow Advocate General sitting in the House of Lords of the British Parliament made comment while speaking out about situation in Tibet at a two-day forum on the development of Tibet held in Lhasa, the capital of Tibet on August 12, organised by the China's Communist regime.

    The UK politician has come under fire for saying that 'the Chinese government has done a great job in developing Tibet to the current stage, where people live happily."

    China's major state-run media has reported that the British lawmaker has told that 'the western media merely write people's happiness in China's Tibet and know little about the type of development taking place in Tibet.'

    Describing economic development in Tibet as "remarkable," Lord Davidson said "many western reports are written by enthusiasts of the Dalai Lama. And they may feel uncomfortable when their presumptions or assumptions are challenged. It is uncomfortable and expensive to have their prejudice challenged."

    "There is a gap between the western media coverage on Tibet and the real Tibet," said, adding: "many western media are profit-making but traveling to Tibet is too costly, which is also a reason why they couldn't come and report on spot in Tibet."

    Uk based Free Tibet Director, Eleanor Byrne-Rosengren said that 'the reports have not been independently verified but if correct, the comments by Lord Davidson at the Chinese government's Fourth Forum on Development of Tibet back Chinese propaganda and provide a deeply misleading picture of life for Tibetans.'

    "We hope that the comments attributed to Lord Davidson significantly misrepresent his contribution at this event. If the reports are accurate, Lord Davidson should have acquainted himself with the facts before regurgitating China's propaganda on Tibet," she said, adding that "in reality, international media are banned from Tibet by the Chinese government."

    "Economic development in Tibet is far from what it seems from the window of a car or a plush meeting room in Lhasa," She said.

    "We must respond to those few governments or officials who make irresponsible statements over Tibet. Furthermore, it creates a bad image of the history of the freedom struggle, entirely against the universal values of freedom and human dignity fundamental to democratic political systems," T.J. Nyima, a Tibetan living in exile told The Tibet Post International.

    "Such irresponsible comments against six million Tibetan people currently suffering oppression also harm the Tibetan people's efforts to expose Tibetan fortitude in the nonviolent struggle," he added, saying "the tour was the first opportunity given to selected foreign delegates to enter Tibet after the de facto ban on foreign officials, Human Rights activists and reporters."

    China is ranked 175th out of 180 countries in the press freedom index that Reporters Without Borders published in February and is more deserving than ever of inclusion in the Reporters Without Borders list of Enemies of the Internet, the latest version of which was issued earlier this month.
    Add your Story Add your Story