1
of 5
More from evereachyu
More iReports you should see
Are You Sure: They Are Working The Chinese Government?
Two Wrongs Don't Make A Right! No Matter What Dalai Lama Says, The Facts Will Never Be Changed. Today's Tibet Is Better Than 50 years ago. Tibetans have more freedom today than Dalai Lama was in Lhasa. Dalai Lama had more slaves than his followers today. （4月22日）达赖在纽约柯盖特(Colgate )大学演讲，主题是《快乐的艺术》。然而在会场之外一片愤怒的抗议之声。大约有500人从上午十点开始就在出现在会场外抗议示威，其中有50多位来自柯盖特大学和附近四所高校的华裔师生。 负责联络这次示威的柯盖特大学的老师龙小宁介绍说，所有的师生都是自发聚集到这里。这些学生分别来自柯盖特大学、苏尼大学的宾哈姆顿分校、雪城大学等柯盖特大学只有五名中国留学生，全部参加了今天的抗议活动。留学生们手中高举中国国旗及英语标语，还展出宣传北京奥运及抗议达赖和西方媒体的图片。学生们从上午十点开始一直持续到下午五点演讲结束，在会场外抗议示威七个小时，向进出演讲的人说明西藏事实真相。他们高喊"达赖停止撒谎"、"媒体必须公正报道"等口号，十分引人注目。 在抗议人群中，有400多名来自美国、加拿大及中国西藏等藏传佛教示威者，抗议达赖说谎。 美国中文网陈少风Colgate大学报道：今天（4月22日）达赖在Colgate 大学做演讲，介绍新书《快乐的艺术》。然而在达赖进入会场之前场外已经是一片抗议之声。大约有500人从上午十点开始就在出现在会场外抗议示威。这其中有 50多位来自Colgate大学附近高校的华裔师生。 根据高露洁大学的老师龙小宁介绍说，所有的师生都是自发聚集到这里。这些学生分别来自高露洁大学、 SUNY大学的Binghamton分校，Cornell大学，Hamilton College，雪城大学。他们的手中高举英语标语图片，中国国旗，从上午十点开始一直持续到下午五点演讲结束，都在会场外抗议，向进出演讲的人说明西藏事实真相。 他们高喊"达赖停止撒谎"、"媒体必须公正报道",等口号。而在这群学生中，更有来自Cornell大学的张慧同学，她就是因身穿反藏独T-shirt，在课堂上和老师激辩而闻名网络那名女学生. 在现场还有400多人的示威者，他们是藏人和佛教徒的抗议者。这些抗议者中还有很多是白人，他们是来自十多个国家的佛教分支信徒。抗议者说达赖根本没有给藏族人民一个宗教自由。 Appeared on iReports used in CNN's news coverage Man Caught by Police Urinating in Car Gas Tank on Video » Posted by: bloomutoday Apr 24, 2008 more iReports on CNN » more iReport superstars » Up for an Assignment? » topics in the news today The lives of soldiers lost What does your church mean to you? Severe weather More expensive to eat Pain at the pump more assignments » upload a story » Need Help? » tell your story like a pro The Ingredients of a Good Story Take Great Photos Shoot Better Video Record the Sound of Your Story iReport Blog » keep up with what's new and what's comingIt's a draw! Put a smile on your face Hello there! Home > iReports > Story German scholar refutes Dalai's claim of "cultural genocide" in Tibet Posted by: Johnathan // 10 hours ago // viewed 52 times embed media German scholar refutes Dalai's claim of "cultural genocide" in Tibet http://www.chinaview.cn/index.htm 2008-04-24 17:40:02 Print Special report: Tibet: Its Past and Present by Ban Wei BERLIN, April 23 (Xinhua) -- A German sinologist and ethnologist on Wednesday refuted the Dalai Lama's claim that the Chinese government has conducted "cultural genocide" in Tibet and criticized some Western media for not letting the voices of ordinary Tibetans be heard. CULTURAL GENOCIDE? COMPLETELY WRONG "The concept of 'cultural genocide' is completely wrong," said Ingo Nentwig, who chairs the research department of the Museum of Ethnology in Leipzig, in a written interview with Xinhua. "The Tibetan culture flourishes and prospers in China," including "language, literature, study of oral literature, everyday life and traditional architecture," he said. Nentwig said that China has published a vast collection of books, newspapers and magazines in Tibetan language, and "there are a lot of Tibetan publishing houses, not only in Tibet but also in the neighboring provinces and even in Beijing." Tibetan authors write in the Tibetan language and Chinese, Tibetan translation of foreign books are also available in China, and "there is an academy for traditional Tibetan medicine in Lhasa," he cited the example to illustrate his point. The scholar said that unlike "some representatives of the clerical elite demanding independence for Tibet or just wanting to exert political power" who describe the modernization of the Tibetan society as "cultural genocide," "most Tibetans recognize the opportunities in a modern Tibet, which is part of China and open to the modern world." SYSTEMATIC ASSIMILATION? OUT OF THE QUESTION Nentwig said a systematic immigration and assimilation of Tibet "through a Han-Chinese (China's majority ethnic group) settlement invasion is just out of the question." "If you come to Lhasa, you actually have the impression that there are many Han-Chinese who account for more than 50 percent of the population in Lhasa for sure," he said, but noting the bulk of them, however, stay there only temporarily. Soldiers, for example, are to leave after demobilization, many construction workers are just there for road or railway projects, some officials are assigned to work in Tibet on a rotation basis and then leave. While some business people operate stores or restaurants there, but they seldom intend for a long-term stay, he said. "But once you leave Lhasa, you hardly meet any Han-Chinese," said Nentwig, who spent a month in Tibet for a field research on yak shepherds in the summer of 2002. "I did my field research in a county where just 20 or 30 Han-Chinese live among 50,000 to 60,000 Tibetans," he said. The scholar said the overall proportion of long-term Han residents in Tibet is about just 7 percent, while ethnic Tibetans account for over 90 percent. Even taking the short-term residents into account, the Han people account for an estimated 20 to 25 percent of entire population in Tibet, while ethnic Tibetans are still the "overwhelming majority of about 75 to 80 percent," he said. Areas inhabited by ethnic Tibetans in the neighboring provinces of Qinghai, Gansu, Sichuan and Yunnan, however, are ethically and culturally more diversified, where Tibetans have coexisted peacefully with Han and other ethnic groups such as Hui, Mongolian, Qiang, Tu and Salar for many centuries, Nentwig said. If exiled Tibetans, under the "anti-assimilation" or "anti-sinicization" slogans, want to fight for Tibetans' cultural or political dominance, this would go against the historical truth and would be unfair for all other residents there, he said. OLD RULING CLASS' ACCUSATION? DIFFERENT STORY TO TELL The scholar listed some historical and geographical reasons for Tibet's relatively slow development compared with other Chinese regions. Tibet is "unsuitable for a comprehensive industrialization and its agriculture is also handicapped by natural conditions" as large grazing areas there have "such thin topsoil that virtually nothing can be cultivated," he said. He also called attention to the fact that before 1950, there were no hospitals and no schools except the monastic education. While acknowledging such huge gap "can not be narrowed overnight," Nentwig noted with delight that the average life expectancy in Tibet has raised from 35 years in the 1950s to the present 67 years. He hailed the liberation of the vast majority of the Tibetan people from the bondage of serfdom as a "great progress," adding most Tibetans are in much better conditions now than 50 years ago. He said the Chinese government's ethnic policy is "enormously generous" and there are many examples to illustrate that China's ethnic minorities are given preferential treatments. "The Tibetans, for example, may basically have two children ... (and) Tibetans in the countryside may have three or even more children" while the one-child policy is applied to the Han. "The latest census showed that in the past 20 to 30 years, the population growth rate of Tibetans was much higher than that of the Han," he said. Nentwig criticized some Western media for only reporting the voices of the former ruling class, namely, representatives of the old theocracy, the clerical and feudal aristocrats, who lost their power and can "no longer exploit the people at will," while ignoring the voices of the ordinary Tibetan people who "have a totally different story to tell." Admitting that China's approach to ethnic minorities still has much room for improvement, he said if anyone wants to criticize China, such criticism should be concrete, constructive and based on expertise. "It helps nobody if unqualified nonsense is disseminated as many Western media unfortunately have done and are still doing," he said.
- TAGS:
What do you think of this story?
Select one of the options below. Your feedback will help tell CNN producers what to do with this iReport. If you'd like, you can explain your choice in the comments below.
Be and editor! Choose an option below:
iReport welcomes a lively discussion, so comments on iReports are not pre-screened before they post. See the iReport community guidelines for details about content that is not welcome on iReport.
© 2011 Cable News Network. 
Comments