About this iReport
  • Approved for CNN

  • Click to view RStewartIII's profile
    Posted May 26, 2009 by
    Wichita Falls, Texas
    This iReport is part of an assignment:
    Sotomayor's confirmation

    More from RStewartIII

    The Brilliance of Nominating Sotomayor


    Today, President Barak Obama announced his pick to replace Justice Souter on the US Supreme Court.  This person is Judge Sonia Sotomayor, a judge on the 2nd Court of Appeals.  While it is hard to say whether this is a good choice, it is a brilliant nomination choice for.


    1>  President Obama has chosen a nominee that will have little-to-no opposition from the Democratic majority in the Senate.


    2>  While Justice Souter is a moderate-to-liberal justice, Obama is basically setting up a more liberal stance with a younger judge that can be on the Supreme Court for at least 18-25 years. This can also set Sotomayor up for Chief Justice because of her potential longevity in the Supreme Court.


    3>  The race/sex card.  While it is often repeated and emphasised that her nomination is not based on sex/race, everyone knows that this is a card that will be played.  Anyone who brings up either sex or race will set themselves up for being labeled sexist or racist, tarnishing their reputation.  While sex/race/religion should not make a difference, we would be ignorant to not understand how this can be used by both sides, and with the Republicans/Conservatives in the minority in the Senate, this will certainly be brought up to discredit their opposition to Sotomayor.


    4>  Opposing opinion states that Sotomayor is an 'activist' judge, and would possibly be a justice that legislates from the bench.  However, I think that if this is her style, then Obama may be setting up the start of a Supreme Court that harkens back to the days of the Warren Court.


    While I have yet to voice my personal opinion about Sotomayer's nomination, I wanted to visit the reasonings behind the appointment, which are sure to ensure Sotomayor's appointment as a Supreme Court Justice.

    Add your Story Add your Story