Share this on:
 E-mail
208
VIEWS
 
RECOMMENDS
7
SHARES
About this iReport
  • Not vetted for CNN

  • Click to view FirozeH's profile
    Posted July 4, 2009 by
    Location
    Mumbai, India
    Assignment
    Assignment
    This iReport is part of an assignment:
    Asia's cultural diversity

    More from FirozeH

    IT"S OKAY TO BE GAY IN INDIA

     

    The recent court decision legalizing same sex unions - gays, lesbians and so on - is quite naturally making news headlines all over the country. As always, the reaction is mixed, ranging from celebration to outright condemnation.

     

    Gays have been around for thousands of years, of course: the most famous historical figure being Alexander the Great. More recently, Oscar Wilde was one of the few who dared to come out of the closet. But they rarely displayed their sexual orientation as openly and proudly as they do now. The predominant feeling was one of shame. Part of the reason could be religious. All the world’s major religions have always regarded homosexuality as an unnatural state – one of the temptations a good man is expected to struggle against. The West is highly critical of Islam’s strict intolerance of homosexuality, but they forget that their Christian Bible has strictures against it too. Moreover, if one believes in the Biblical proclamation to go forth and procreate, it becomes evident that same sex liaisons are not what God had in mind. That is why I have a problem with this new concept - particularly in the USA - of gay marriages. If one subscribes to the view of marriage as a holy communion, how can one expect God to bless a union He considers unnatural?

     

    I an aware that some scientists are trying to prove that homosexuality and lesbianism is in one’s genes and, consequently, beyond one’s control, but I would consider that a cop out. I would submit that, in common with all mammals, primitive urges like rage and uncontrolled sex are inbuilt in all of us. What separates us from the animals is our ability to control them. For thousands of years of years of human history, homosexuality (I am using that term generically to denote all same sex liaisons) was regarded as something to be ashamed of and suppressed: one of the temptations we prayed to Our Father not to lead us into. It has become acceptable only during the last thirty years; a mere blimp in the human experience.

     

    Nowadays, people of either sex do not feel the slightest need to conceal their sexual orientation. They act upon their urges as soon as they discover them – as if it is the most natural thing in the world. There is no introspection, no feeling of right and wrong. It is enjoyable, so it must be all right. It is a natural urge, so why try to suppress it? Many of our natural urges – like sex, whenever the inclination strikes one - are, in fact, kept in check by social and religious strictures. Yes, illicit sexual liaisons have become less furtive and more frequent in recent times, but the strictures still play an effective role in preventing society from degenerating into a bacchanalian love fest. Gay sex, however, has suddenly burst out of the closet with a ferocity and abandon rarely witnessed in human history. It is not only acceptable to be gay, it is to be celebrated. (Gay “married” couples are being featured on the front page of US newspapers- for pete’s sake).

     

    Even if one was to accept that homosexuals have got a raw deal through the millennia, is the pendulum swinging too far to the other side? Take this issue of gays in the military; and the policy of ‘don’t ask, don’t tell’. Can one honestly say that the presence of gay men in a platoon would not be a source of friction? Their officers may not ask, but the men would come to know soon enough. I’m not sure how things would develop in a life and death situation. And what about legalization of gay marriages? It took centuries of social change for women to even get the vote. And now – in the space of a few years - the gays expect, almost demand, that their legal union be blessed by the state; and by society.

     

    I cannot help wondering if there is a certain amount of hypocrisy involved here, even among the ‘liberals’ who proclaim that gays are as ‘equal’ as any other segment of society. If one or more of their children declared that they are gay, the ‘liberal’ parents may accept it – even with good grace – but can they place their hands on their hearts and declare that they would be overjoyed at the revelation? Would a father beam with pride when his son told him he had a male lover? It is time to get real, folks.

     

    In conclusion, then, I would submit that the coming out of homosexuals is a momentous social change. Leaving aside the merits or otherwise, it needs time to be assimilated by society as a whole. The gays have already come a long way in a remarkably short time. It would not be wise to push their luck.

    What do you think of this story?

    Select one of the options below. Your feedback will help tell CNN producers what to do with this iReport. If you'd like, you can explain your choice in the comments below.
    Be and editor! Choose an option below:
      Awesome! Put this on TV! Almost! Needs work. This submission violates iReport's community guidelines.

    Comments

    Log in to comment

    iReport welcomes a lively discussion, so comments on iReports are not pre-screened before they post. See the iReport community guidelines for details about content that is not welcome on iReport.

    Add your Story Add your Story