Share this on:
About this iReport
  • Not verified by CNN

  • Click to view gedwards's profile
    Posted April 7, 2012 by
    This iReport is part of an assignment:
    Is Obama's health care law constitutional?

    More from gedwards

    If it's Constitutional, then explain....


    If mandating the purchase of HC is OK, since it results in helping people who otherwise wouldn't be helped, it's allowed under regulating commerce, and it's an aspect of promoting the "general welfare," then why couldn't the Federal Government mandate the following for the exact same reasons?


    - Kidney donations. "As of late 2010, a total of approximately 93,000 patients were registered on the kidney transplant waiting list at the United Network for Organ Sharing (UNOS) in the United States " The list would go down to zero if it was mandated that people hand over their extra kidney. For a cash reimbursement of course, to make it commerce.


    - New car purchasing. Why bother with an auto bail out? Just mandate that people must purchase a new car from GM or Chrysler every three years or so. That's commerce, will save or create jobs, is good for the economy, etc.


    - Open membership at Augusta National Golf Club. The Club no doubt purchases food, accepts sponsorships from companies, contributes to the local economy, has a financial arrangement with the PGA, and deals with national media. Each of those things, and others, affects commerce. So under anti-discrimination laws and the commerce clause. the Federal government should have the authority to mandate membership rules.


    - Scholarships with no preconditions. If an organization awards scholarships, then they must do so without preconditions. No discrimination, no focusing a particular group, no disqualifications because of the applicant's attributes.


    So what would be the difference and prevent the Obama Administration from mandating any or all of the above?

    What do you think of this story?

    Select one of the options below. Your feedback will help tell CNN producers what to do with this iReport. If you'd like, you can explain your choice in the comments below.
    Be and editor! Choose an option below:
      Awesome! Put this on TV! Almost! Needs work. This submission violates iReport's community guidelines.


    Log in to comment

    iReport welcomes a lively discussion, so comments on iReports are not pre-screened before they post. See the iReport community guidelines for details about content that is not welcome on iReport.

    Add your Story Add your Story